A white dress beside dark water appears twice in these ten works. In Francis Danby’s wooded hollow, a young woman has drawn up her knees and hidden her face. By Ivan Kramskoi’s pond, another sits quite at ease, with room for someone beside her on the bench. A sheltered corner of a garden will do equally well for grief or for a quiet evening. It will also serve for a lovers’ meeting. Much depends on who else happens to come along, as the couple in the first painting might have discovered.
Private Encounters
The Tryst
Samuel Colman · mid-1830s

The two people who have arranged to meet at Colman’s gate are remarkably easy to miss. One dark coat blends into the hedge. The other figure is mostly hidden by the first. Farther off, on the right, a light burns in the window of a house.
Colman has put the brightest patch of moonlight far out on the water. The eye goes there first and comes back by way of the trees to the pale rails of the gate. Only then do the two heads come into focus. For a few moments the lovers have had the garden to themselves, even with us standing at the foot of the steps.
The Enchantress
Heinrich Lossow · 1868

The gentleman in the gold coat has chosen a dangerous partner. The sphinx he leans forward to kiss has a woman’s face and the body of a lion. In the poem by Heinrich Heine that inspired Lossow, the kiss brings a stone sphinx to life. As she draws the poet to her, her claws tear into him.
Lossow stops a moment earlier. The sphinx tips her chin towards the gentleman and he holds her paw as he might a lady’s hand. His fine coat is brushing the undergrowth. There is a gentle absurdity about all this courtliness in the shrubbery, until you look again at the paw he has taken so readily in his own.
Disappointed Love
Francis Danby · 1821

Scraps of a letter float among the lily pads. On the bank beside the young woman lie a miniature portrait and other letters. She has kept the likeness, whatever news that letter brought. We can piece together something of her afternoon from these small belongings, though Danby allows us no view of her face. She has buried it in her arms.
When Disappointed Love appeared at the Royal Academy in 1821, Danby was living in Bristol. He knew the wooded banks of the Avon Gorge well. Here the trees lean so far over the pool that their reflections darken the water almost to the colour of the earth. The red shawl catches the eye from across a room. To see the pieces of paper, you have to come closer.
Walls, Water and Wilderness
The Rose Garden
Ferdinand Keller · 1908

It is broad daylight in The Rose Garden. A white building on the far hillside catches the sun, yet down by the pool it might be several hours later. The cypresses explain the difference. Keller gives them so much room on this tall canvas that even the top of the picture cuts through their crowns.
At the foot of the trees the scale is quite different. Clipped box hedges follow the edges of the beds. Two small figures have stopped by the water, where a pale column marks the turn of a path. The hedges reach only a little way up the column. Follow a cypress trunk upwards from the same spot and the difference in scale is startling.
Old German Folk Tale
Hermann Hendrich · c. 1896

On a grassy bank a man in dark clothes leans back as a woman reaches towards him. He moves a hand in her direction. There is a stretch of empty grass between their hands. The title promises an old folk tale but gives us neither a name for the stranger nor any assurance that it would be wise to follow her.
Hendrich leaves the woman’s nature to the paint. The man’s dark sleeve has a firm edge against the grass. Pale blue runs through the hem of her dress and reappears in the little stream at her feet. It is difficult to say quite where she meets the ground. Hendrich later helped create the Nibelungenhalle at Königswinter to exhibit his paintings of Wagner’s legends. Here a figure on a riverbank is quite enough to introduce the supernatural.
Donkey Skin
Gustave Doré, engraved by Héliodore Pisan · illustration for Charles Perrault’s Donkey Skin

The princess is still in her court gown. In Charles Perrault’s tale, her father has declared that he means to marry her. Doré shows her slipping out to seek her godmother, the Lilac Fairy. The donkey skin she will wear as a disguise comes later. For now she must get down the steps with that long train sweeping behind her.
High above her, the moon picks out the turrets of the palace. The stairway is harder to read. Héliodore Pisan, who engraved Doré’s drawing on wood, cut fine lines to catch the light on the stone. Near the hem of the gown, the marks broaden until we can make out a tread and judge its depth. For all the extravagance of the castle, it is easy to imagine having to find one’s footing here in the dark.
The Hours of Evening
The Perfume of Flowers
Nikolay Sergeyev · 1910

The flowers have grown in among the columns of Sergeyev’s terrace. Petals lie scattered on the paving, some caught in the narrow joints between the tiles. Neither woman has picked a bouquet. The title names something they can enjoy simply by being there.
The woman in pink still stands beside a column. Her companion has settled on the terrace and leans back on one arm. Patches of evening light fall across the tiles and over her white skirt, breaking up its outline. Beyond the balustrade the trees have already gone dark. Down here one can still see the colour of a fallen petal.
Nocturnal Paradise
Ludovic Alleaume · oil on canvas, undated

A man kneels at a seated woman’s feet, his head in her lap. He might have turned to her for comfort. A label on the wooden frame that supports the canvas gives their meeting a more precise meaning. It records the fuller title Paradis nocturne – Déclaration, identifying his gesture as a declaration of love.
It is a surprisingly public place for such a confidence. The paved terrace stretches away to the right and the two stone urns, each planted with flowers, would make a handsome setting for a party. The man has turned his back on all of it. We can make out the bend of his dark coat against the woman’s dress. Her expression, which would tell us most about his chances, is much harder to see.
Night Time Paradises – Lunar Calm
Ludovic Alleaume · canvas stamped 1928

The yellow folding chairs are among the least grand things in this garden and surely the most inviting. In one, a woman in a pale dress has tipped her head back. Her companion sits a little straighter beside her. Beyond them, a white statue stands on its pedestal and pink flowers edge the lawn. The woman has a better view of the stars from where she sits.
Alleaume uses two quite different lights on the villa. Moonlight gives the walls the cool, chalky colour of the garden statue. A few upstairs panes glow yellow from within. Someone else might still be awake up there. After the urgent embrace in Nocturnal Paradise, there is pleasure in finding two people sufficiently at ease together to sit back in their chairs.
Moonlit Night
Ivan Kramskoi · 1880

When this picture was first exhibited in 1880, its title was simply Night. Its first owner, the collector Sergei Tretyakov, could also see it as a portrait. His wife Elena posed for the seated figure when he commissioned the work from Kramskoi. One arm rests along the back of the bench. The folds of her skirt have settled across her knees.
The dress looks white, although Kramskoi painted much of it grey. A few pale folds at the sleeve and knees are enough to suggest moonlight on the whole length of the gown. Elsewhere the light is fainter. A tree trunk comes into view behind the bench, then the edge of the path. By the time the water lilies emerge at the lower left, the dark patch beside her has opened into a pond.